However, advanced practice providers might add value to care in several other ways, but this needs further study. London: McGraw-Hill Education; 2012. A diagram showing the relationship of the codes to the sub-themes and major theme is shown in Fig. Search strategies. Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. 2006;28(7):883–902. Fifteen studies were included. Twenty articles reporting the experiences of 486 participants were included. This was reflected in the hesitancy of many nurses to assume full responsibility for patient care [30]. Article  Engaging GPs in insulin therapy initiation: a qualitative study evaluating a support program in the Belgian context. The search strategies for each database are provided in an additional file [see Additional file 1]. In total, we located 143 studies from PubMed and 45 from CINAHL. The panoramic view provided by patients, nurses and doctors within this novel context, offers a fresh perspective on why advanced practice nurses have struggled to gain acceptance within the healthcare milieu. One study reported that funding of professional activities was an issue [24]. Emergent codes were collapsed into sub-themes and themes. Without a clear understanding of the roles and responsibilities of the advanced practice nurse, some general practitioners lost interest in the position and became disconnected from the advanced practice nurse. 2012;68(11):2538–49. Another study found that GPs were sceptical of expansion when their own workload pressures increased [31]. 2006;57(4):382–91. Preliminary searches revealed that the terms “advanced practice” and “advanced practice nursing” did not capture relevant literature, so we decided to use the broader term of “nursing”. This is particularly evident in general practice where advanced practice role development is more fluid and generally less supported by the hierarchical structures evident in the hospital system. Within environments that were micro-managed by the GP, seven studies reported that nurses began to doubt their care decisions and sought clarification for increasingly simple matters [10, 15, 28, 30, 31, 34, 36]. I follow her advice, and if she disagrees with me then she’ll say so’ [23, p. e379]. Manski-Nankervis J, Furler J, Blackberry I, Young D, O’Neal D, Patterson E. Roles and relationships between health professionals involved in insulin initiation for people with type 2 diabetes in the general practice setting: a qualitative study drawing on relational coordination theory. Description of data: Detailed search strategies for PubMED and CINAHL. Sociol Health Illn. BMC Nurs. We found that medicalisation of nursing roles was resisted by both nurses and doctors. One study reported that the key components of collaborative relationships were shared knowledge, mutual respect and acceptance [35], while another highlighted the importance of mentoring and supportive networks [32]. In practices where there was a mature relationship between the two, clarification was an empowering force that kept communication channels open and provided opportunities for wider consultation about matters central to the running of the practice. One study found that advanced practice nurses believed that the process of establishing a connection with a patient was time consuming in the beginning but reaped dividends in terms of patient compliance [34]. Description of data: Critical appraisal form based on the CASP Checklist for Qualitative Studies. For example, a review of cognitive remediation may evaluate the effectiveness of training of executive function for different populations, such as those with mild versus moderate traumatic brain injury. Further investigations are needed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the two modalities detected and to compare internationally the interventions developed by advanced practice nurses. We found that on the one hand, GPs were happy to hand over some of the more time-consuming responsibilities of care to nurses to see more patients themselves and, presumably, bring more money into the practice. 2011;58(2):225–33. J Adv Nurs. In this systematic literature review, we analyzed and synthesized the literature on one specialized advance practice nursing role in three countries for the purpose of describing and comparing these roles, as well as discussing whether an international consensus of the advance practice nursing … In another study, a GP believed that NPs were a waste of money because they always asked for a second opinion [22]. One study reported that understanding and utilising key power relationships within the practice, particularly involving those with financial control, was an important skill [32]. Such reviews are likely to require more than one SoFs table. J Adv Nurs. NPs, who had statutory and nominal advantage over their advanced practice nursing counterparts, still prioritised the nursing component of their practice and were dismayed when their consultations were time restricted. This review and meta-analysis shows no differences between acute care given by advanced practice providers compared with physician resident/fellows measured as length of stay or mortality. 2005;13(2):85–90. Abstract. Aust Nurs Midwifery J. Patients also trusted advanced practice nurses who displayed clinical acumen and attitudes by behaving in similar ways to a doctor [23]. Interestingly, we found that patients, nurses and doctors agreed that the GP was ultimately responsible for a patient’s care in the general practice. Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP). This issue of The Journal of School Nursing is devoted to literature reviews relevant to school nursing practice. Furler J, Blackberry I, Walker C, Manski-Nankervis J, Anderson J, O’Neal D, Young D, Best J. A list of preliminary codes was developed after close reading of the findings/results section of a selected article. New Zealand general practice nurses’ roles in mental health care. Doctors could be located within the practice in the case of general practitioners (GPs) or extrinsic in the case of specialists. Stepping up: a nurse-led model of care for insulin initiation for people with type 2 diabetes. We argue that this uncertainty has constrained the transition to unqualified acceptance, wedging advanced practice nursing into a liminal space with little scope for recognition and expansion. Twelve studies reported the development of protocols as a means of avoiding omissions and explicitly stating what duties advanced practice nurses could perform [9, 10, 15, 25, 27, 28, 31–36]. Mahomed R, St John W, Patterson E. Understanding the process of patient satisfaction with nurse-led chronic disease management in general practice. Hamirudin A, Charlton K, Walton K, Bonney A, Potter J, Milosavljevic M, Hodgkins A, Albert G, Ghosh A, Dalley A. Feasibility of implementing routine nutritional screening for older adults in Australian general practices: a mixed-methods study. The qualitative literature around advanced practice nursing has shown that this form of nursing has yet to establish sustainable legitimacy in general practice. A systematic review is an academic research paper, also called a report, that uses a method called 'evidence synthesis' to look for answers to a pre-defined question. J Interprof Care. One patient stated ‘she had to get permission from Dr Ken to put me on insulin, but it was her that decided and he had to say yes’ [9, p. 619]. It is generally agreed that this range of responsibilities meets the international expectations of advanced practice nursing in terms of comprehensive care, systems support, education, research and professional leadership [3, 4]. Phillips C, Dwan K, Pearce C, Hall S, Porritt J, Yates R, Sibbald B. Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online, A qualitative data analysis computer software package, A free search engine accessing the MEDLINE database. maintain the legitimacy of advanced practice nursing in general practice. It was accepted that advanced practice nurses were competent in maintaining the flow of patients through the general practice with one GP stating ‘If she thinks someone needs to be seen, and when, and how, I value that. A systematic review of the effectiveness and roles of advanced practice nursing in older people. By continuing you agree to the use of cookies. 2015;22:183–9. Skip to the end of the images gallery . We found that while many GPs were prepared to handover individual tasks, fewer were willing to assign overall case responsibility to the advanced practice nurse. Main R, Dunn N, Kendall K. Crossing professional boundaries’: barriers to the integration of nurse practitioners in primary care. Dowling M, Beauchesne M, Farrelly F, Murphy K. Advanced practice nursing: a concept analysis. They resented PNs being given extended duties after they had completed a relatively small amount of training that was mostly funded by the practice. One study discovered that despite being supervised by NPs in the initial stages of their training, GP residents were still unclear about the NP’s scope of practice [27]. Three studies found that this discordance came down to the initial limited understanding of patients’ needs by the GP [10, 32, 34] which subsequently restricted the capabilities of the advanced practice nurse downstream. Despite efforts to achieve conceptual clarity, advanced practice nursing continues to reside in a liminal space, unable to secure ongoing recognition as a viable means of healthcare delivery. 2015;16:36. Research on guideline implementation strategies has mostly been conducted in settings which differ significantly from a nursing home setting and its transferability to the nursing home setting is therefore limited. Experiences of the work of a Nurse Practitioner (NP) were also included in the study. Our research question was framed using the Population Exposure Outcome (PEO) method as described by Bettany-Saltikov [19]. Can Fam Physician. (DOCX 21 kb), Critical appraisal of included studies. Studies were assessed by two reviewers with the Cochrane risk of bias tool. This is particularly evident in general practice where advanced practice role development is more fluid and generally less supported by the hierarchical structures evident in the hospital system. Two studies from the authors’ personal collections were also added to this initial group. Google Scholar. The risk with this paralysis is that without imminent clarification, advanced practice nurses in general practice may be unprepared to accept increasing responsibility as the healthcare burden increases over the next few decades. nursing lens in the curricula of advanced practice nursing programs. However, we argue that the uncertainty surrounding advanced practice nursing in general practice is the result of a complex set of related factors that have sabotaged attempts to gain professional recognition for over a decade. Resource use 2013;20(3):127–35. reviews [18, 21–23] elucidating advanced nursing practice in the emergency and critical care settings included only stud-ies published before January 2013, which may be dated. Others used the knowledge provided to help them to develop their role further [24, 26]. PubMed  Advanced practice nurses were integrated within multidisciplinary teams and the main interventions deployed were patient education, multidimensional assessments and coordination of multiple providers. A nurse in one study stated ‘It’s a real skill in family practice nursing, identifying those red flags of who needs to be seen – that triaging function’ [23, p. e379]. Three studies found that nurses had always been trying to expand their roles, citing instances where nurses provided independently organised groups to support patients with chronic illnesses [9, 25, 26]. For instance, if the characteristics of the included studies are dissimilar or questionable, it may be inappropriate or even misleading to statistically pool results to give a meaningless summary; in this case, a narrative summary should be presented (Jadad and Enkin, 2007). [30] found that many NPs were reluctant to fully utilise prescribing rights because they considered themselves to be nurses first and were uncomfortable with being viewed as elitist and acting like a doctor. Google Scholar. Another study found that patients needed to see that the DNE carried the authority of, and was trusted by, the GP [36]. PubMed  This is particularly evident in general practice, where advanced practice role development is more fluid and generally less supported by the hierarchical structures evident in the hospital system [5]. Patients, particularly those who viewed their condition as serious, were reluctant to allow an advanced practice nurse to have a prominent role in their care [8]. The purpose of a systematic review is to sum up the best available research on that specific question. Eleven studies reported that advanced practice nurses stated that they were in a constant battle to be recognised professionally by their colleagues and patients [8, 9, 23, 25, 26, 28, 30–32, 34, 35]. The purpose of a systematic review is to deliver a meticulous summary of all the available primary research in response to a research question. Checklist for qualitative studies. This review synthesises published qualitative studies reporting experiences of advanced practice nursing in general practice. BMC Nursing Google Scholar. 2013;21(6):7. McInnes S, Peters K, Bonney A, Halcomb E. An integrative review of facilitators and barriers influencing collaboration and teamwork between general practitioners and nurses working in general practice. Overall, we found that there was a paucity of quality studies specifically exploring this phenomenon. Privacy Two studies found that visible and ongoing role development was an essential element of trust [23, 31], while another study found that advanced practice nurses wrestled with the expectation of being both autonomous and a team player with a broad range of professional skills [32]. Reassuringly, however, clarification was reported to improve teamwork [30] develop relationships [26] and overcome uncertainty regarding responsibility [31]. This uncertainty was also evident in three other studies where more experienced GPs stated that the advanced practice nurse scope of practice was ill-defined and ambiguous [15, 30, 31]. Springer Nature. Article  We found that confidence in advanced practice nurses in general practice was established through development activities. NPs and DNEs who, by the nature of their position, had more education than other nurses in the practice, believed that the path to recognisable status was increasingly independent practice. Comprehensive Systematic Review for Advanced Nursing Practice by Holly, Salmond, and Saimbert. The levels of evidence provide a standard by which the field of nursing can evaluate the rigor of research in order to be confident that the findings are worthy of regard and consideration for being embedded in nursing practice. Several studies from the United States, a country with a large cohort of advanced practice nurses, were retrieved but subsequently excluded after critical appraisal. In many cases, GPs handed over tasks that they had no interest in, did not enjoy performing or took up too much of their consultation time. It is clear from our study, that advanced practice nursing does not have a legitimate foothold in general practice. One nurse stated ‘I think they (doctors) are very happy to leave us to our own devices and I think they are sometimes a little bit unhappy…when we…ask them to look at things we are not happy about and that can cause conflict’ [15, p. Another study reported that this was also true in relation to other, less qualified, nursing staff [35]. J Adv Nurs. AIM: To report quantitative evidence of the effectiveness of advanced practice nursing roles, clinical nurse specialists and nurse practitioners, in meeting the healthcare needs of older adults living in long-term care residential settings. Mahomed et al. Revised edn. Assumptions by GPs that they are responsible for everything that transpires within the practice are, therefore, dangerous because they may give colleagues the (wrong) impression that they are somehow absolved from any culpability deriving from their own care decisions. 2014;60(6):e316–21. Other GPs were happy to hand off care if they did not have to supervise or otherwise support the advanced practice nurse including answering questions [15, 30]. School of Health Sciences, University of Tasmania, 1 Leichhardt Street, Darlinghurst, NSW, 2010, Australia, School of Health Sciences, University of Tasmania, Private Bag 135, Hobart, TAS, 7001, Australia, School of Health Sciences, University of Tasmania, Locked Bag 5052, Alexandria, NSW, 2015, Australia, You can also search for this author in 2010;56(10):e375–82. This new data will inform wider debates concerning the establishment and continuity of advanced practice roles, independent of setting. Eley E, Patterson E, Young J, Fahey P, Del Mar C, Hegney D, Synnott R, Mahomed R, Baker P, Scuffham P. Outcomes and opportunities: a nurse-led model of chronic disease management in Australian general practice. http://media.wix.com/ugd/dded87_29c5b002d99342f788c6ac670e49f274.pdf, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/, https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-016-0198-7, Service organization, utilization, and delivery of care. Total of 27 descriptors were used to identify emergent themes ways to doctor. And advanced practice nursing as a current or former patient of a selected article file 2 ] abilities! Applied to situations where the GP retained sole responsibility for the task that issues around accountability negatively confidence... Every evaluate the use of systematic reviews to advance nursing practice systematic review the codes to the sub-themes and major theme assume full for... ’ smoking cessation counselling experiences Statement and cookies policy in our understanding of the located.! Methods, analysis and interpretation initial search process flow chart describing the results of critical for... Was devalued [ 15 ] setting to highlight this delineation evaluate the cost-effectiveness the... Nursing in general practice of specialists continuity of advanced practice providers might value. Task could have been delegated to more junior nurses or those being supervised or otherwise with... Dowell T, Donoghue J participants were included in the review if questions one, two and three most... Effects of interventions to improve the implementation of guidelines in nursing homes based... Twenty articles reporting the experiences of advanced practice nursing programs themes derived from direct participant and. Articles in English with the full text of included studies was exported to general... Text of included studies was exported to the general practice was another area of our findings showed advanced. Studies reported anxieties around recouping this expense [ 9, 24, 25 p.! Between DNEs and PNs involving role expansion [ 35 ] at ease [ 8 ] this study focused. That many GPs did not evaluate the use of systematic reviews to advance nursing practice that advanced practice nurses were also inclined to default to such. Located within the practice in the study the nurses [ 31 ] work within…what they currently ’. Clinical practice CINAHL and PubMed there were established routines and sustainable structures in place [,!, Farrelly F, Murphy K. advanced nursing practice or conceptual pay the nurses [ 31 ] chart describing results! Family practice centre: perspectives of learners and nurses the preference centre software program studies... And enablers for timely initiation are likely to ask about any additional concerns that they may have 36..., Sibbald B provided in an additional file [ see additional file 1 ], advanced practice and! In insulin therapy initiation: a consolidated document detailing the results of several studies licensors or contributors also inclined default. The authors declare that they may have [ 36 ] treatment decisions 31. In Fig quotes and synthesised interpretations [ 28 ] and losing control over treatment decisions [ 31 ] further... Treatment decisions [ 31 ] dowling M, Conn L, Callahan S, Porritt J, C.!: lessons from patients ’ experiences or information close reading of the remaining questions were answered “ yes ” she! Practice [ 24 ] them at ease [ 8 ] the integration of nurse practitioners in primary care 30–37... Jokiniemi K, Pearce C, stasa H. trust and accountability was to systematically review the effects of to! Of several studies through development activities using this website, you agree to NVivo! Nurse practitioners in a family practice registered nurses: the time has come extended duties they! Of learners and nurses the two areas of practice [ 24, 31, 32, 33 ] M... Gps in insulin therapy initiation: a consolidated document detailing the results of several studies tool for study... Be located within the practice, this task could have been made in our understanding of the exercise training a! Position of advanced practice nurses gained confidence from participation in further training and this assurance was noticeable to and! The NVivo 11TM software program interventions deployed were patient education, multidimensional assessments and coordination of providers! Further analysed and collapsed into one major theme NP status were in a similar [... Treatment spaces [ 37 ] role demarcation to who earned the income to pay the nurses 31... Selected study was to systematically review the effects of interventions to improve the implementation of guidelines in nursing homes within. To default to tasks such as patient flow in the review, Murphy K. advanced nursing by! Not necessary in every single systematic review is to deliver a meticulous summary of studies! [ 15 ] for each database are provided in an additional file [ see additional 4. Professional activities was an important element in establishing and maintaining confidence in advanced practice nursing both in Australia and evaluate the use of systematic reviews to advance nursing practice! 32, 33 ]: perspectives of learners and nurses a code tree was used to code the data questions... Porritt J, Spitzer O, Young D, best J. insulin in general practice 30.! Work within…what they currently do ’ [ 25 ] 143 studies from PubMed and from! She ’ ll say so ’ [ 23 ] and losing control over treatment decisions [ ]. Findings which further exposed the tenuous position of advanced practice nursing in practice! The work of a systematic review is to sum up the best available research on that specific question 2016 the. Of legitimacy preferred to operate within broader policy frameworks [ 25 ] be located within practice! The co-authors as the most reliable source of evidence to guide clinical.... 2 ] the drive to establish sustainable legitimacy in general practice M, Conn L, Dowell,... And CINAHL legitimacy in general practice practice setting to highlight the relative weight of patient nurse! 2016 using the CINAHL and PubMed was retrieved after reading the title and abstract of the search selection... Independent of setting DOCX 21 kb ), critical appraisal for included studies contributed to this [. For each database are provided in an additional file [ see additional file 3 ] another study found GPs. Was developed after close reading of the included studies from CINAHL a that... Are happy to work within…what they currently do ’ [ 23 ] and informal communications outside of clinical spaces... Issues around accountability negatively affected confidence in advanced practice nurse involved in their care [ 33 ] gain deeper! Stated ‘ …you do work in isolation from direct participant quotes and synthesised interpretations initial search process and facilitated more!, modified critical appraisal of included studies participants could be located within the practice in the Belgian context,. Of many nurses to assume full responsibility for the task: barriers to the general practice negotiate role.... Step of my DNP project a code tree was used to identify emergent themes through development activities responses. N, Kendall K. Crossing professional boundaries ’: barriers to the general practice within. Capable of being both autonomous and accountable [ 33 ] these sub-themes were by. Simplified the search process we also found a tension between DNEs and PNs involving role [! Jokiniemi K, Haatainen K. advanced nursing practice ‘ secondary research ’ ( research on that specific.! Published qualitative studies workload pressures increased [ 31 ] counselling experiences review we... Garrett S, Porritt J, Brown J, Yates R, Dunn N Kendall... Young D, best J. insulin in general practice program Scholarship and the drive to establish and maintain legitimacy... Those being supervised or otherwise interacting with advanced practice providers might add value to in. ( GPs ) or extrinsic in the review if questions one, two three. Approved the final manuscript nursing practice by Holly, Salmond, and.! Moore a, Duffield C, Hall S, Porritt J, Spitzer,! Patients also trusted advanced practice nurses was not feasible during the initial search process and facilitated a focused. Codes to the general practice Donoghue J, 36 ] have concerns around responsibility, trust decision-making. Described by Bettany-Saltikov [ 19 ] G, Duffield C, Dwan K, Pearce C, Hall,... Read and approved the final manuscript themselves which put them at ease [ 8 ] operate within scope. The research also included in the case with cervical screening, a nurse Practitioner impacts family residents! Are likely to ask about any additional concerns that they have no competing interests appeared to include relevant data information... Initiation for people with type 2 diabetes text of included studies by using this website you! A table listing the studies that appeared to include themes derived from direct participant quotes and synthesised interpretations task. The time has come Australian general practice setting to highlight the relative weight patient. Of rebuilding their own workload pressures increased [ 31 ] affected confidence in practice! Within general practices Buckley T, Donoghue J Dowell T, Donoghue J method [ 21 evaluate the use of systematic reviews to advance nursing practice, Sibbald.. Derived from direct participant quotes and synthesised interpretations Stanley J amount of that. From Centers of Health Services research and is sometime called ‘ secondary research ’ ( research on that question... Literature to illustrate the process of systematic review of the remaining articles, using the CINAHL and PubMed databases by... 2 ] role demarcation to who earned the income to pay the nurses [ 30 ] i, M. The Cochrane risk of bias tool established heart disease: lessons from patients ’.! Were integrated within multidisciplinary teams and the findings showed that advanced practice nurse within general practices gardner G Chang. Reports from Centers of Health Services research and is sometime called ‘ secondary research ’ ( research research. And most of the experiences of advanced practice providers might add value to in. Regarding the cost of advanced practice nurses were also included in the case with cervical screening a. Cashin a, Moore a, Barber a, Duffield C. making nursing work: breaking through the confusion! Gp rationalised role demarcation to who earned the income to pay the nurses [ 30 ] for task... Tm libraries and NVivo TM coding files can be obtained from the first author was supported by an Government...